A cheaper freight quote has more exclusions; is it really cheaper?
What's your go-to way of comparing two quotes when their line items don't match?
All questionsLogistics
9 replies
- Build a common scope from collection to the agreed delivery point, then put each quote against it. Empty cells are questions to resolve, not zero-cost services. I'd give the comparison a final row for unresolved items. That prevents the cheapest-looking total from winning while half its destination costs remain unknown. Once both providers confirm the same scope, the price difference becomes something you can actually make a decision with.
- Ask each provider to identify what could still be charged later. The exclusions often tell you more than the bold total at the bottom.
- Use the same cargo dimensions, weight, equipment and dates. Otherwise you're comparing different jobs before you even reach the terms.
- Check the currency and conversion basis. A small rate advantage can disappear if one quote uses an unfavorable exchange calculation.
- Don't ignore validity. A quote that expires before cargo readiness isn't necessarily a price you can use.
- For variable charges, show a range or an explicit assumption. Pretending every item is fixed makes the comparison look easier than it is.
- Ask who owns the handoffs at origin and destination. A cheap rate with unclear coordination can require a lot more work from your team.
- Once the scopes are aligned, send the comparison back for confirmation. It gives each provider a chance to correct a misunderstanding before you choose.
- The lowest complete quote may still win, of course. You just want to know that the saving is real and not a missing part of the shipment.
Write a reply
Loading…